IMPLEMENTATION CHALLENGES
Communication
Finances
Professional Development
Scheduling
School Facilities
Technology
Computer Training, Lab Time, and Equipment
The following
observations regarding logistical obstacles were expressed in interviews
with Project participants.
"Obstacles can
really get in the way of good theory," says media literacy coach Jeff
Share with a smile. "Finding time, finding the digital camera that's
been borrowed, dealing with a video player that doesn't work and teachers
who've been pulled out for training," are some of the difficulties
that crop up."
"It's important,"
says CML President and CEO Tessa Jolls, "not to let logistics interfere
with the true purpose of the project."
Communication
"Because it is so
complex with so many people involved, technology itself enables the
Project," Jolls explains. "Without e-mail it wouldn't have been possible."
An online virtual
community at www.nicenet.org, established in Year 3 of SMARTArt, keeps
participants informed of workshop schedules, coaching sessions, and
more. It provides access to lesson plans, curricular resource materials,
and coach Share's "Demonstration Lesson Notes," which describe classroom
media literacy activities taking place as the Project progressed.
Finances
Getting contract
monies released isn't always easy, according to Jolls. Grant funds are
sent directly to the lead education agency, LAUSD, and the Center for
Media Literacy has a contract with them, but delays occur. For instance,
"grant monies released in October were not distributed until June,"
Jolls says. In general, internal bureaucracies of schools and districts
are not geared to working with community partners easily.
"The federal government
is trying to encourage outside partnerships with schools and with
outside agencies," Jolls says. "Often, however, schools are unprepared
for handling the business side of that relationship; so you have to
be prepared for that."
Professional
Development
The biggest hurdle
in professional development, according to coach Share, is that "most
teachers feel overly restricted by the mandated Open Court program and
the excessive constraints of testing and preparing for testing. Teachers
really need perspective about the big goals of education to balance
what the students need with all the new school requirements," he says.
"This is where media literacy can help to focus teachers on the critical
thinking skills that will help their students far more than the mere
acquisition of isolated facts."
Share asserts that
"the comment I hear most often from teachers is 'This is what I really
want to be doing but I'm overwhelmed by all the testing I have to do,
and Open Court, and other mandated curricula.' Open Court is a huge
program and to implement it takes more time than is available; that's
how it is designed," says Share. "It takes a teacher with confidence
to be able to not do some of the things they're told to do because they
know they're doing what the kids really need."
Another challenge
is that traditional teacher preparation courses focus more on theory
than on implementation. Teachers need to have enough experience to trust
their intuition and do something different than how they were taught
in college.
Scheduling
The three tracks
at this year-round school make Project scheduling incredibly complex.
Working on alternating schedules, the school year for Track A teachers
begins in August and ends in June; Track B goes from July to June; and
Track C from July to April. Leo Politi's multitrack system works on
a model called "Concept 6" in which every four months one track comprising
of one third of the school's students and teachers rotates off for two
months of vacation while a different track rotates on.
Three school tracks
make it cumbersome to schedule artists. For instance, exposing all SMARTArt
students to the four visual and performing arts disciplines meant that
in Year 3 eight artist/educators made four to six visits to each of
the 16 Project teachers' classrooms.
Year-round schools
add a level of complexity to everything, even media literacy demonstration
programs.
School
Facilities
"The year-round
facilities at the elementary school are under stress," Jolls says. "There
is no break between tracks; when one goes off on a Friday, another begins
the following Monday." Group facilities, such as an auditorium that
is constantly in use, need maintenance. Problems with overbooking the
multi-purpose auditorium occurred in the first two years when dance,
or other instructional sessions that required more space, were not available
when needed.
Technology
The shift in the
Project's last year to having teachers produce the student animations
is a big one. In the first two years, students produced their 30-second
PSAs with AnimAction professional artists in a one-day workshop. In
FY2003-2004 teachers were trained to use The BOX! Animation Production
Studio™ with four classroom coaching sessions supporting the endeavor.
Computer
Training, Lab Time, and Equipment
The school provides teachers with limited professional development in
computer technology, none of it in the classroom. Students' time in
the computer lab is approximately 40 minutes-to-one hour once a week.
Classroom computers
are typically older than those in the computer lab. In both areas, limited
technical support means the equipment needs maintenance. Currently,
one technical assistant works in the lab three hours a day.
The school's lab
is supplied with a good selection of technology tools, but more digital
cameras and camcorders would better accommodate media literacy studies.
Presently equipment includes:
- 25 Macintosh
computers
- 1 PC to use
with The BOX! Animation Production Studio™
- Various software,
ranging from HyperStudio® and KidPix® to Microsoft Office® and Power
Point®. Skill-building software includes Thinking Things® and other
vocabulary and math programs.
- Three digital
cameras
- Two camcorders
- One TV and one
VCR
Generally, lack
of computer training and lab time, and minimal maintenance of technology
equipment are common areas of difficulty in public schools. Until those
items receive more attention in the educational system, "you have to
be realistic in what you expect from teachers," Jolls says. On the up
side, dedicated teachers can sometimes find ways to get around technical
difficulties. When the school's TV and VCR were broken, some teachers
brought in their own from home; one SMARTArt teacher bought this equipment
for his classroom. In 2004, two TVs and two VCRs were purchased with
funds from the Project's budget.
Back
to top |